WS Factory 5712 Rep

Patek Philippe Nautilus 5712 model is produced by PPF Factory with a solid stainless steel case, standard case diameter and high-precision automatic Super Clone movement architecture. It is among the most successful 1:1 super clone watch reviews on the market, with its sapphire crystal AR coating glass, original case tolerances and detailed workmanship.

Just last week a new name emerged and announced that their 5712 had a few significant improvements. After reading the promotional content about this watch, I was really hopeful. But after seeing the real watch, I have to say, it's not the best either.

Let's first look at the quality of WS's 5712.

Dial and Hand Details

Does it use the SW dial as they claim?
No. Although the dial is good and very close to the SW dial, the moon phase is completely different. See the picture below; The watch on the left is WS 5712, and the watch on the right is PPF 5712 with SW dial. The moon phase background of WS 5712 is too blue and its star is larger, which does not look good.

And the hour and minute hands of the WS 5712 do indeed have a solid center hub, but the shape is not correct.

Are the eagle's beak-shaped ears of this watch really as perfect as the factory claims?
No. See the picture below; The 5712 from WS Factory on the left really has a better ear shape, but compared to the CNC case, the ear of WS 5712 is not perfect.

The CNC case has a very good ear shape.

Movement and Caliber Performance

Although PPF has improved the engravings of the previous 240 movement, the movement engravings still appear to be slightly thinner and shallower than that of the movement in the WS 5712. But the movement engravings on both watches do not look as clean as those of the original.

Case and Body Workmanship

Finally, the case thickness of the WS 5712 is approximately 8.6 mm. A good watch, but not as good as they claim. I do not recommend spending so much money on this watch.