Which factory produces the best replica Rolex Oyster Perpetual? EW, Clean or VS?

Comprehensive comparative analysis of Which Factory Produces the Best Replica Rolex Oyster Perpetual? Ew Clean Or and Mi models: Case finishes, movement precision, dial details and production tolerances are examined in detail with Saat Detective expertise standards.

Movement and Caliber Performance

The mechanism is the most important part, so let's talk about that first. When buying a replica Rolex Datejust or 41mm Submariner, you may have encountered salesmen always telling you that the VS factory makes the best; because they use Dandong 3235 movement. This mechanism is indeed the biggest selling point of many replica watches from the VS factory, including the 36 mm and 41 mm Oyster Perpetual. VS claims that this movement has a 72-hour power reserve, but a customer of mine tested it; The maximum power reserve it could reach was 60 hours. And now VS fits this movement into the Oyster Perpetual 36 mm and 41 mm models that do not have a date function, but you have to pull the crown to the third position when setting the time. The second position should be for setting the date, but it doesn't work on the Oyster Perpetual; This gives the user a not very good usage experience.

Clean uses the Shanghai 3230 movement in 124300 and 126000. This movement is also very stable and has a 48-hour power reserve. When you pull the crown to the first position, you can wind the watch, and when you pull it to the second position, you can directly adjust the time. Unlike the Dandong 3235, the Shanghai 3230 has a similar time setting to the original.

The movement used by EW is a 7 series automatic movement produced by Hangzhou Watch Factory. Few people have heard of Hangzhou movements, but I examined the movement on their website and saw that the power reserve is up to 80 hours. Someone who bought an EW watch before said that one of their watches could reach 86 hours; This is truly incredible.

So in terms of mechanism, all three are fine; It cannot be said that VS 3235 is necessarily the best.

When it comes to workmanship, I have to say that VS is in a tough spot among the three, considering the price. I compared VS and Clean's Datejust models and saw that Clean has better workmanship, especially on the dial. So I will say this: this puts VS in a tough spot when it starts making replicas of 126000 and 124300. Because these Oyster Perpetual models cannot fully reflect the advantage of the 3235 movement, the workmanship of the watch is not as good as Clean, but the prices are much higher than EW; This is a really difficult situation. However, EW has a flagship model among these Oyster Perpetual watches: the one with a Tiffany blue dial. It is said that EW's boss took an original watch to disassemble, so the case shape is very close to the original and the Tiffany blue color is the most accurate. This is EW's flagship model in Oyster Perpetual, and many watch enthusiasts show high acceptance to this replica. Going back to the Oyster Perpetual replicas made by VS, there is no flagship model out there like EW's Tiffany blue.

Dial and Hand Details

So, after examining the movement, workmanship and dial between VS, Clean and EW, if you are looking for your first Rolex replica watch in the Oyster Perpetual series, I recommend you to buy an EW. If you already have a replica watch collection and are just getting a super clone, then I recommend Clean. If there is a particular model you have your heart set on, like the Tiffany blue color, then I would only recommend EW.

Photos of the EW factory's flagship Oyster Perpetual watch; tiffany blue in 36mm.